Land Revenue Systems and Economy
NCERT Class 8 - Our Pasts III • NCERT Class 12 - Themes in Indian History Part III, Chapter 10
Land Revenue Systems and Economy
British revenue policy had one aim - a large, fixed and punctual income. Three systems were used in different regions, and all three raised the demand, made it payable only in cash, and enforced it strictly, which transformed rural society.
The three systems
| System | Introduced by | Region | Revenue paid by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Permanent Settlement | Cornwallis, 1793 | Bengal, Bihar, Odisha | Zamindar |
| Ryotwari | Thomas Munro | Madras, Bombay, Assam | Individual cultivator (ryot) |
| Mahalwari | Holt Mackenzie and R. M. Bird | North-Western Provinces, Punjab | Village or mahal as a body |
- Permanent Settlement made the zamindar the owner of the land, with the revenue fixed forever. Fixing it permanently meant the state gained nothing from later increases in production or prices.
- The Sunset Law provided that if the amount was not paid by sunset on the due date, the estate would be auctioned, which transferred many old zamindaris to city merchants and moneylenders.
- Ryotwari dealt directly with the cultivator and removed the intermediary, but the assessment was high and revised periodically, leaving the ryot exposed to bad harvests.
- Mahalwari assessed the village jointly, with the headmen responsible for collection; the settlement was revised every twenty to thirty years.
- In all three the demand had to be paid in cash on a fixed date, regardless of harvest, which drove peasants to moneylenders.
Commercial crops and rural distress
- Peasants were pushed towards crops the market wanted - indigo, cotton, opium, jute, tea and sugarcane - rather than food grains.
- The indigo system in Bengal forced cultivators to plant indigo on their best land at a fixed low price; the Indigo Revolt of 1859-60 followed, and a commission ended the worst abuses.
- Debt to the moneylender became structural, and land began passing from cultivators to non-cultivating creditors.
- Famines became frequent and severe in the later nineteenth century, with heavy mortality, even as grain continued to be exported.
Deindustrialisation and the drain
- Indian handloom textiles lost both their export market and their home market as machine-made British cloth entered duty-free while Indian cloth faced heavy duties in Britain.
- Weavers, spinners and other artisans returned to the land, so the share of population dependent on agriculture rose - the reverse of what happened in industrialising countries.
- Dadabhai Naoroji set out the drain of wealth theory in *Poverty and Un-British Rule in India*, arguing that a large part of India's wealth left the country every year with no equivalent return.
- The drain took the form of home charges, salaries and pensions of British officials, interest on debt raised in Britain, and profits of British firms.
- Railways, begun with the Bombay to Thane line in 1853 under Dalhousie, carried raw material out and manufactures in; they helped integrate the market, but the capital came on a guaranteed return paid from Indian revenues.
हिंदी संकेत: तीनों व्यवस्थाओं में कर देने वाला कौन है - यही मुख्य अंतर है। स्थायी बंदोबस्त में जमींदार, रैयतवाड़ी में किसान स्वयं, महालवाड़ी में पूरा गांव।
Exam me kaise aata hai
Match-the-following on system, region and originator is almost guaranteed. Factual questions ask the year of the Permanent Settlement and what the Sunset Law was. Application questions ask why the cash demand increased peasant indebtedness, and who first argued the drain theory.
UPSC / State PSC ke liye
The analytical point is risk transfer - the state fixed its income and passed all the risk of drought, flood and price fall to the cultivator. On deindustrialisation, note the current historiographical caution: the decline of handicrafts is well established, but its scale and timing are debated, so state it as a trend rather than a precise figure.
Yahan confuse hote hain
✗ The Ryotwari system was introduced by Cornwallis | ✓ Cornwallis introduced the Permanent Settlement; Munro introduced Ryotwari
✗ In Mahalwari the zamindar paid the revenue | ✓ The village or mahal as a body was responsible
✗ The Permanent Settlement was revised every thirty years | ✓ It was fixed permanently; Mahalwari was periodically revised
Ek nazar me
- Permanent Settlement 1793 by Cornwallis in Bengal, Bihar and Odisha, revenue from zamindars.
- Sunset Law auctioned estates whose revenue was not paid on time.
- Ryotwari by Munro in Madras and Bombay dealt directly with the cultivator.
- Mahalwari by Holt Mackenzie and R. M. Bird assessed the whole village.
- Cash demand on a fixed date pushed peasants to moneylenders; Indigo Revolt in 1859-60.
- Dadabhai Naoroji gave the drain of wealth theory; first railway line Bombay to Thane in 1853.
